• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Kid Safety First Logo

Kid Safety First

  • Car Seats
    • Car Seat Buying Guides
      • Best Convertible Car Seat Buying Guide
    • Infant Seats (USA)
      • Britax B-Safe Review
      • Britax B-Safe 35 Infant Car Seat Review
      • Britax Chaperone Review
      • Britax Endeavours Infant Car Seat Review
      • Chicco Keyfit 30 Review
      • Maxi-Cosi Mico Review
      • Peg Perego SIP 30/30 Review
      • Peg Perego 4-35 Review
      • Safety 1st Infant Car Seats Reviewed
      • Infant Comparison Reviews
        • Britax B-Safe vs B-Safe 35 Infant Seats – Comparison Review
        • Britax B-Safe vs B-Safe 35 Elite Reviewed
        • Britax B-Safe 35 vs B-Safe 35 Elite Reviewed
        • Britax B-Safe 35 Elite vs Endeavours – Comparison Review
        • Britax B-Safe 35 vs Britax Endeavours Comparison Review
        • Britax B-Safe 35 vs B-Safe Ultra Compared
        • Britax B-Safe Ultra Car Seat Review
        • Britax B-Safe 35 Elite vs B-Safe Ultra Compared
        • Britax Endeavours vs B-Safe Ultra Infant Seats Compared
        • Chicco Keyfit 30 vs Keyfit 30 Zip – A Comparison Review
        • Chicco Keyfit 30 vs Keyfit 30 Zip Air Compared
        • Maxi-Cosi Mico AP vs Mico Max 30 Compared
        • Peg Perego Primo Viaggio 4-35 vs Nido Compared
    • Convertible Seats (USA)
      • Britax Advocate ClickTight ARB Review
      • Britax Boulevard ClickTight ARB Review
      • Britax Marathon ClickTight Review
      • Britax Roundabout G4.1 Review
      • Chicco Nextfit 65 Review
      • Clek Fllo Review 2023
      • Clek Foonf Review
      • Diono Olympia Review
      • Diono Pacifica Review
      • Diono Radian RXT Review
      • Diono Rainier Review
      • Graco Contender 65 Review
      • Graco Extend2Fit Convertible Seat Review
      • Graco Size4Me 65 Convertible Review
      • Maxi-Cosi Pria 70 With TinyFit Review
      • Maxi-Cosi Pria 85 Review
      • Peg Perego Convertible Car Seat Review
      • Recaro Performance Racer Review
      • Recaro Performance Ride Review
      • Recaro ProRide Review
      • Convertible Seat Comparisons
        • Britax Advocate ClickTight vs Boulevard ClickTight
        • Britax Advocate ClickTight v Boulevard ClickTight Review
        • Britax Advocate ClickTight vs Marathon ClickTight
        • Britax Advocate ClickTight v Marathon ClickTight Review
        • Britax Boulevard ClickTight v Marathon ClickTight Review
        • Britax Boulevard ClickTight vs Chicco Nextfit Zip Compared
        • Britax Marathon ClickTight vs Chicco Nextfit 65 Compared
        • Britax Marathon ClickTight vs Maxi-Cosi Pria 70 Compared
        • Britax Roundabout G4.1 vs Marathon G4.1 Compared
        • Britax Roundabout G4.1 vs Boulevard G4.1 Compared
        • Chicco Nextfit 65 vs Nextfit iX Zip – Comparison Review
        • Chicco Nextfit iX vs Nextfit iX Zip Compared
        • Chicco Nextfit 65 vs Nextfit iX Zip LUXE Compared
        • Chicco Nextfit 65 vs Nextfit iX – Comparison Review
        • Chicco Nextfit iX vs Nextfit iX Zip Air – Comparison Review
        • Diono Rainier vs Diono Olympia
        • Diono Pacifica vs Diono Olympia – A Comparison Review
        • Diono Rainier vs Diono Pacifica
        • Graco Contender vs Size4Me Seats Compared
        • Maxi-Cosi Pria 70 vs Pria 85 Compared
        • Maxi-Cosi Pria 70 vs Vello 70 Comparison Review
        • Recaro ProRIDE vs Performance RIDE
        • Recaro Performance Racer vs Rally Review
        • Recaro Performance Racer vs Roadster Comparison Review
        • Recaro Performance Rally vs Roadster Comparison Review
    • Combination Harness-2-Booster Seats (USA)
      • Britax Pioneer 70 Review
      • Britax Frontier 90 Review
      • Britax Pinnacle 90 Review
      • Diono Radian RXT Review
      • Diono Ranier Review
      • Seat Comparison Reviews
        • Britax Frontier 90 vs Pioneer 70
        • Britax Frontier 90 vs Recaro Performance Sport
        • Britax Pinnacle 90 vs Pioneer 70
        • Britax Pinnacle 90 vs Frontier 90
        • Britax Pinnacle 90 vs Recaro Performance Sport
        • Clek Foonf vs Fllo Review
        • Diono Radian RXT vs Radian R120 – Comparison Review
        • Diono Radian RXT vs Diono Rainier
        • Graco 4Ever All-in-One vs Milestone All-in-One Compared
        • Peg Perego Viaggio HBB 120 vs Flex 120 Compared
        • Recaro Performance Racer vs Rally Review
        • Recaro ProRIDE vs Performance RIDE
    • Booster Seats (USA)
      • Chicco Kidfit vs Kidfit Zip Booster Seats Compared
      • Clek Oobr Booster Seat Review
      • Peg Perego Primo Viaggio Flex 120 Booster Seat Review
      • Recaro ProRide Review
      • Graco Affix Booster Seat Review
    • Car Seat Bases (USA)
      • Britax B-Safe Base Review
      • Chicco Keyfit 30 Base Review
      • Maxi Cosi Mico Base Review
  • Edges & Corners
    • Prince Lionheart Edges & Corners
  • Fire & Gas
    • Cheap Carbon Monoxide Detector
    • Fireguards
    • Home Fire Ladder
    • Kidde Carbon Monoxide Detectors
    • Plug Carbon Monoxide Detector
  • Indoors
    • Best Furniture Anchors for the Home
    • Childproof Cabinet Locks (USA)
  • Out & About
    • Bikes / Scooters
      • Best Safety Helmets For Toddlers
      • Best Scooter Helmets
      • Giro Scamp MIPS Helmet Review – Safety Helmets For Kids
      • Mini Micro Scooter Review
      • Micro Maxi Scooter Review
      • Micro Sprite Kick Scooter Review
      • Nutcase Little Nutty Bike Helmets Reviewed
      • The Best 3 Wheel Scooters for Kids
    • Reins / Backpacks
      • Child Harness Backpacks
    • Strollers
      • Baby Jogger City Mini Double Review
      • Baby Jogger City Mini GT Double Stroller Review
      • Baby Jogger City Mini Double vs City Mini GT Double
      • The Baby Jogger City Select Stroller Review – 2014 Model
      • Baby Jogger Summit X3 Stroller Review
      • BOB Revolution Pro Stroller Review
      • BOB Revolution Flex vs Revolution Pro Compared
      • BOB Revolution SE vs Revolution Flex Comparison Review
      • BOB Revolution SE vs Revolution Pro Comparison Review
      • Britax B-Agile Travel System Review – 2014 Edition
  • Sleeping Safely
    • Baby Monitors
      • Infant Optics DXR-5 Review
      • Infant Optics DXR-8 Review
      • Philips Avent Dect Review
      • Snuza Hero Baby Movement Monitor
      • V Tech Communications Safe & Sound Review
    • Bed Rails
      • Babydan Sleep n Safe Bed Rail
  • Air Quality
    • Do Air Purifiers Really Work?
  • Blog

Safety 1st Infant Car Seats Reviewed

May 3, 2014 By Kristian

Can You Buy Good Cheap Infant Car Seats?


Safety 1st Infant Car Seats are a much more affordable option than some of the more premium products on the market, but are they any good and should you buy one for your child?

The main problem with infant car seats is that they don’t last very long and you will probably end up having to buy a convertible car seat eventually anyway. Many infant car seats cost as much as $200, which is a lot of money for a product that is unlikely to last for much more than 12 months.

The commonly cited benefits of infant car seats over convertible car seats are:

  • you can carry your baby around in them using the seat’s carry handle
  • they can be used as part of a “baby stroller travel system”.
  • some consider that they fit smaller babies better than convertible seats.

There can be no doubt that infant car seats are a more convenient option for newborn babies than convertible car seats, but many parents choose not to buy them simply because of the extra expense involved.

Fortunately, Safety 1st have manufactured some infant car seats that are much less expensive than premium seats, like the Chicco Keyfit 30, Britax B-Safe and Maxi Cosi Mico AP.

But, what do you get for your money and are these cheaper seats safe and comfortable for your baby to use?

The Safety 1st Infant Car Seats


#1 Safety 1st Comfy Carry Elite Plus

The Safety 1st Comfy Carry Elite Plus is the cheapest of the 3 infant car seats at about $70.

Like the Maxi Cosi Mico AP, the Comfy Carry Elite Plus will accommodate babies weighing between 4 and 22 lbs and up to 29 inches in height. However, unlike the Maxi Cosi Mico AP, this reduced size does not seem to have much of an impact on the weight of the seat. The Mico AP weighs just 8 lbs, whereas this seat still weighs 15 lbs. But, of course, it must be pointed out that it is about $120 cheaper than the Mico AP.

This seat comes with an adjustable head support infant insert and a 5-point harness.

The base (supplied) is belt-fitted and can be adjusted to the appropriate angle within your vehicle.

This is a perfectly safe and functional infant car seat, but you can’t expect the same degree of padding and ease of use as a premium product. The buckle is a bit more difficult to use than other seats and the carry handle isn’t the most ergonomically comfortable one on the market, but it is solid, functional and won’t break the bank.

DISCONTINUED!

#2 Safety 1st OnBoard 35

The Safety 1st OnBoard 35 is slightly more expensive than the Comfy Carry Elite Plus.

This seat is suitable for babies weighing between 4 and 35 lbs and no more than 32 inches tall, and so will last much longer than the Comfy Carry Elite Plus. It comes with a lot of leg room, a 5-point harness, washable insert and side impact protection.

Weighing in at 16.5 lbs, it is only slightly more heavy than the Comfy Carry Elite Plus, despite the fact that is can be used to carry much larger babies.

The 2 most common complaints about the seat are the slightly flimsy canopy and the fact that the base is quite long. So, if you have a very small vehicle, this might be a problem. If in doubt, check with the manufacturer or buy it from an online retailer that offers Free Returns.

Overall, I consider that this is a very good seat for the money and I would certainly prefer it to the Comfy Carry Elite Plus.

DISCONTINUED

#3 Safety 1st OnBoard 35 Air

 

The Safety 1st OnBoard 35 Air comes with the sort of features that you would expect in a premium infant car seat.

It is suitable for babies weighing between 4 and 35 lbs and no more than 32 inches tall and comes with the expected 5-point harness and customisable infant insert. It is much more flexible than the cheaper models and comes with 4 harness heights and 3 buckle locations to accommodate your growing child

The biggest selling point, though, is probably the fact that this seat comes with full body side impact protection. The Air Protect cushion system protects your baby’s head and the GCell HX™ patented foam inside the seat provides superior body protection.

The base is fitted into your vehicle using a simple one-clich LATCH system.

On the downside, the canopy is not very sturdy and the seat it is a little heavy at about 20 lbs. You can actually buy a Britax B-Safe infant car seat for the same price at the moment.

Buy the Safety 1st OnBoard 35 Air.

Can You Use These Seats With a Stroller?


The Safety 1st Clic It Infant Stroller is compatible with all 3 of these seats, in addition to many others.

It is an absolute steal at $60 with Free Shipping.

My Verdict


If you cannot afford to buy a premium $200 infant car seat, you should seriously consider the Safety 1st models mentioned above. I probably wouldn’t recommend the Comfy Carry Elite Plus since the Onboard 35 is only a little bit more expensive, and it will last much longer and also comes with side impact protection.

The OnBoard 35 Air model does have some extra side impact and convenience features, but if I was going to spend about $140 on an infant car seat I would choose the Britax B-Safe instead.

Safety Information


After purchasing any child car seat, you should always read the User Manual thoroughly before using it. It is also advisable to visit your local Fire Department or NHTSA Child Car Seat Inspection Centre to ensure that the seat is definitely suitable for your child’s specific requirements and that you have installed it correctly. These services are usually provided free of charge.

You can find your nearest NHTSA Centre here.

Do You Need More Help?


If you need any further advice or assistance whatsoever, please feel free to contact me and I will do my very best to help.

If you have any feedback about my “Safety 1st Infant Car Seats Reviewed″ post, please feel free to leave a comment in the box below, or send an email to kristian@kidsafetyfirst.com

infant seat reviews

facebookShare on Facebook
TwitterTweet
FollowFollow us
PinterestSave

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Find More Reviews

Featured Comparison Reviews

Chicco OneFit v Fit4 Comparison Review

   vs    If you are looking to buy a car seat for your child, Chicco products should definitely be towards the top of your shortlist of options. They are one of the most well-known and well-respected manufacturers of high-quality premium … [Read More...] about Chicco OneFit v Fit4 Comparison Review

Best Diono All in One Car Seats

Diono All in One Car Seats - Introduction If you are looking for the best Diono all-in-one car seat, you need to take a close look at the Diono Radian 3Q range. The Diono Radian 3Q series of all-on-one car seats was introduced to the US Market as a … [Read More...] about Best Diono All in One Car Seats

Diono Radian Comparison Reviews

Diono Radian Child Car Seats The Diono Radian product line of child car seats has been available to buy in the USA and Canada for many years now. Despite this fact, they have not just stayed the same and become outdated. Instead, Diono have … [Read More...] about Diono Radian Comparison Reviews

Best Diono Harness to Booster Seats 2023

Diono Harness to Booster Seats in 2023 - Introduction If you are looking for the best Diono harness to booster car seat to buy in 2023, you need to look at the Diono Radian 3Q range. The Diono Radian 3Q series of harness to booster car seats was … [Read More...] about Best Diono Harness to Booster Seats 2023

Best Britax Harness to Booster Seat 2023

Britax Harness to Booster Seats in 2023 - Introduction If you are looking for the best Britax harness to booster car seat to buy in 2023, you need to look at the Britax Grow With You product range. The Britax Grow With You series of harness to … [Read More...] about Best Britax Harness to Booster Seat 2023

Britax B Safe Infant Car Seat Reviews

The Britax B Safe Gen2 Infant Car Seats I have recently written a series of in-depth reviews of the latest Britax range of Infant Car Seats, which the B Safe Gen2 series. Those reviews come in the form of both individual car seat reviews and side-by-side … [Read More...] about Britax B Safe Infant Car Seat Reviews

Featured Car Seat Reviews

Britax One4Life ClickTight Review

Britax One4Life ClickTight - Introduction Britax has been making high-end premium infant car seats, convertible car seats, and harness to booster car seats for many years now. Their child car seat products have proved very popular with parents in the USA and … [Read More...] about Britax One4Life ClickTight Review

Britax Grow With You ClickTight Plus Review

Britax Grow With You ClickTight Plus - Introduction The Britax Grow With You ClickTight Plus is a harness-to-booster car seat that effectively replaces the discontinued Britax Pinnacle 90 seat, which was a hugely popular child car seat in the US for many … [Read More...] about Britax Grow With You ClickTight Plus Review

Clek Liing Infant Car Seat Review

Clek Liing Infant Seat - Introduction The Clek company has been manufacturing high quality child car seats for many years. One of their latest infant car seats available for purchase in the US and Canada is the Clek Liing. If you are looking to buy … [Read More...] about Clek Liing Infant Car Seat Review

Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Review

Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Infant Seat - Introduction The Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Infant Car Seat was introduced to the US Market in 2021 and is one of the products that replaces, and improves upon, the older B-Safe 35 and B-Safe Ultra series of … [Read More...] about Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Review

Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Plus Review

Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Plus Infant Seat - Introduction The Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Plus Infant Car Seat was introduced to the US Market in 2021 and effectively replaces, and improves upon, the older B-Safe 35 Elite and Ultra series of … [Read More...] about Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Plus Review

Britax Marathon ClickTight Review

The Britax Marathon ClickTight - Overview The Britax Marathon ClickTight is the entry-level seat in the series. Despite being significantly cheaper than the Advocate and Boulevard seats, it still comes fitted with some pretty impressive safety and … [Read More...] about Britax Marathon ClickTight Review

Recent Posts

  • Infant Car Seats vs All in One Car Seats
    By Kristian
    February 13, 2023
  • Infant Car Seats v Convertible Car Seats
    By Kristian
    January 29, 2023
  • Chicco MyFit Harness to Booster Seat Review
    By Kristian
    January 18, 2023
  • Best Harness to Booster Seat Under $200
    By Kristian
    January 12, 2023
  • Best Harness to Booster Seats 2023
    By Kristian
    December 30, 2022
  • Chicco Fit4 Adapt v OneFit Compared
    By Kristian
    December 5, 2022
  • Chicco OneFit v Fit4 Comparison Review
    By Kristian
    November 29, 2022
  • Best Car Seats For Newborns
    By Kristian
    November 24, 2022
  • Best All in One Car Seats 2023
    By Kristian
    November 24, 2022
  • Best Convertible Car Seat 2023
    By Kristian
    November 23, 2022
  • Best All in One Car Seats For Small Cars
    By Kristian
    November 22, 2022
  • Best Infant Car Seats 2023
    By Kristian
    November 21, 2022

Car Seat Comparison #2

Best Diono All in One Car Seats

Diono All in One Car Seats - Introduction If you are looking for the best Diono all-in-one car seat, you need to take a close look at the Diono … [Read More...] about Best Diono All in One Car Seats

Featured Car Seat Reviews

Britax One4Life ClickTight Review

Britax One4Life ClickTight - Introduction Britax has been making high-end premium infant car seats, convertible car seats, and harness to booster car seats for many years now. Their child car seat products have proved very popular with parents in the USA and … [Read More...] about Britax One4Life ClickTight Review

Britax Grow With You ClickTight Plus Review

Britax Grow With You ClickTight Plus - Introduction The Britax Grow With You ClickTight Plus is a harness-to-booster car seat that effectively replaces the discontinued Britax Pinnacle 90 seat, which was a hugely popular child car seat in the US for many … [Read More...] about Britax Grow With You ClickTight Plus Review

Clek Liing Infant Car Seat Review

Clek Liing Infant Seat - Introduction The Clek company has been manufacturing high quality child car seats for many years. One of their latest infant car seats available for purchase in the US and Canada is the Clek Liing. If you are looking to buy … [Read More...] about Clek Liing Infant Car Seat Review

Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Review

Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Infant Seat - Introduction The Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Infant Car Seat was introduced to the US Market in 2021 and is one of the products that replaces, and improves upon, the older B-Safe 35 and B-Safe Ultra series of … [Read More...] about Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Review

Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Plus Review

Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Plus Infant Seat - Introduction The Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Plus Infant Car Seat was introduced to the US Market in 2021 and effectively replaces, and improves upon, the older B-Safe 35 Elite and Ultra series of … [Read More...] about Britax B-Safe Gen2 Flexfit Plus Review

Britax Marathon ClickTight Review

The Britax Marathon ClickTight - Overview The Britax Marathon ClickTight is the entry-level seat in the series. Despite being significantly cheaper than the Advocate and Boulevard seats, it still comes fitted with some pretty impressive safety and … [Read More...] about Britax Marathon ClickTight Review

Footer

Legal Stuff

  • Affiliate Disclosure Statement
  • Privacy Policy

© 2024 Kid Safety First - All Rights Reserved